TrueScotsman
Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
“Point to one example of a successful so-called national liberation movement that has not ended up administering the system of production for the market with to a realizing profit.”
Building socialism is a process. Who are you to criticise how actual, real world socialists arrive at the destination?
“Nelson Mandela was another ‘national liberator” who collaborated with the ruling class.”
True, but why? The collapse of the USSR. There was no more support from actual socialists.
“So why are you here, then?”
Hopefully to prevent any actual socialists from wasting their time joining your mutual masturbatio…sorry, “party”.
“In the Panama paper (like Putin’s investments)”
Lol, Putin isn’t mentioned in
the CIA op aka the Panama papers.“Gaddafi also had a net worth of more than 200 billion dollars”
BS printed in Fortune magazine, the only reason for being which is to denigrate socialism and to trumpet the superiority of capitalism. And here you are using it as a source as if any of the fanciful nonsense emanating from it is God’s honest truth. Pathetic. As I’ll explain again for the simpletons; the pretzeled reasoning that Gadaafi was fabulously wealthy is that because much of the nation’s resources were nationalised and therefore the property of the state, and that Gadaafi was the head of state therefore all the nation’s nationalised wealth was his! The reasoning is so tortured it has PTSD.
“Musk’s himself said that the only one who has more money than him is Putin”
And what qualifies the charlatan and snake oil salesman Elon Musk as being any kind of expert as to
Putin’s wealth?“he was a colonel of the KGB controlled by gangsters”
Evidence?
“and all those gangsters became part of the Russian capitalist class”
All of them? Every single one? BS.
“they are part of the organized crime in Latin America, and they have investment using straw man in banks, real estate, tourism. hotels, money laundering, drugs, and mining.”
Evidence?
“The so-called land reform ( Mision Zamora ) made in Venezuela took place by authorizing peoples and military to take lands and houses from other peoples under the plan poor vs rich.”
Isn’t that what class struggle is?
“That type of action create a violent situation and several criminal groups were promoted.”
So you don’t believe in class struggle or revolutions? What a funny “socialist” you are.
“Now those groups are part of the organized crime that has spread thru South America ( Tren de Aragua ) by the meantime the government officials were getting rich and richer, and they were also involved in drug trafficking.”
BS.
“Lefties always need heroes, and then those heroes become part of the ruling class, then they get disappointed and grab another hero, and the eternal cycle continues all the time, from failure into failures”
No, we need leaders. Heroes are a happy byproduct.
“I do not know how Gaddafi can be a hero when he ordered a terrorist attack against an airplane carrying 270 innocents peoples”
He didn’t. Lockerbie was carried out by Iran in retaliation for the US shooting down one of their passenger planes.
“he was a terrorist like the same ones that overthrew him”
Bourgeois lies spread by smooth brained simpletons.
“On the contrary, your contempt for socialist opposition to such bourgeois constructs as so-called “national liberation movements””
National liberation movements are bourgeois constructs? Lol. In an alternate universe maybe. All of Africa, all of Asia, the whole of the Americas? No place is pure enough to please you? What clowns you are. The only True Scotsmen. What a lonely, hateful, pathetic gaggle of misfits you are. A mutual masturbation society with no happy endings. Only scorn, derision and spite. You are a truly worthless nest of participation trophy winners.
“reveals just how thoroughly reactionary and conservative you truly are.”
Lol. Because anti-colonialism is reactionary don’t you know?!
“All of these movements without exception have ended up fully embracing capitalism.”
Complete fantasy. But it is true that there have been failures. Why? Because of US and European aggression and support of counter-revolutions, coups and murder. Read “Killing Hope” by William Blum to learn the full scale of the US’ counter revolutionary project since WW2. But you won’t be sympathetic to the struggles of real world socialists because you’re not interested in the real world only the fantasy one that exists in your head where there is no counter revolutionary violence and betrayal. Toddlers have a better understanding of the real
world than you lot.“Some of them ended up even worse than their erstwhile colonial masters (with whom many of them continued to do business) in their degree of corruption, and repression of the local workers and peasants.”
Which ones and why?
“For an antisocialist supporter of the disgusting imperialist capitalist regime of Putin”
Russia is not imperialist.
“you have some nerve for criticizing others for not endorsing your cherished bourgeois notion of anti-colonial struggle”
Lol. Serious question. How many people are in your “party”? I count about seven. There are 93 million in the CPC. Who’s winning the battle of ideas you or them? Your party has no followers because you’re hateful, infantile fanatics with absolutely no understanding of the real world. You will always be irrelevant. Thank god for that.
“when your very own beloved hero is at this very moment exemplifying his commitment to colonialism by annexing new territories with the intention of expanding “mother Russia”.
Putin did everything possible to avoid the conflict. Put simply, Kiev lost all right to rule over its Russian speaking minority when it attempted to ethnically cleanse them from the east. The population of the liberated regions happily voted to rejoin their historic motherland. Are you going to deny them agency and object? Well, they don’t give a shit because you’re a useless, brainwashed simp for your country’s ruling class. You are irrelevant and your views don’t matter a jot.
“So I take it spelling is not your strong suit, is it, DS?”
What an own! I feel mortally wounded. What can I say, guess I have fat fingers. L.
“You have a constant tendency to mock the referenced claims of others without providing any evidence whatsoever to demonstrate that these claims are false. You expect others to believe you just because it is your opinion?”
You lie. I constantly provide evidence supporting my claims.
The Guardian is a mouth piece of the British establishment. It is as trustworthy as a used car salesman running a Ponzi scheme. The fact you credulously quote from it is a sign of just how politically unsophisticated you are. Guardian Bros, lol.
The extent of Mugabe’s assets “unknown”, “rumored”, hardly convincing. The Panama papers were a CIA op.
https://www.cnbc.com/2016/04/12/swiss-banker-whistleblower-cia-behind-panama-papers.html
“He needs a “colonial-oscopy”!”
Your contempt for the anticolinial struggle reveals your true reactionary colors. If this group isn’t an MI6 psyop it bloody well should be.
“In fact, the similarity between Hitler’s Nazism and the Nazism of Stalin, Mao, Kim, etc. is UNCANNY!”
Oh dear, time to hand out another participation trophy. Give me a break guys, I have a family to feed, why are you making me waste my money so? This award goes to the special boy who only today almost learned to tie his shoe laces. A few more years and I know you’ll get there. Congratulations! Communists are Nazis! Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!
“Mugabe the man mainly responsibe for the Gukurahundi genocide. The International Association of Genocide Scholars estimated that 20,000 individuals lost their lives during this.”
Lol. And there’s a genocide going on in Xinjiang China too, right? Only, no bodies, no evidence, just the mewlings of Wahabist/Christian/anti-communist fanatics. Which are you Bojo’s Brain? Don’t answer that, I already know.
“According to some estimates, Robert Mugabe has about £1bn-worth of assets…”
The Guardian? Lol. Socialist Posers Guardian Bros of the world unite and do your part in spreading bourgeois imperialist propaganda. Knobbo, you know all MSM has that beat covered, right? SPGB, champions of ruling class dogma, hurrah!
“Land Reform – a Bolshevik euphemism for rural mass murder.”
Funny how you lot sound just like bourgeois propagandists. Bravo.
“No doubt Dave Spart would also add to his list of “Goodies”:”
Actually Bojo’s Brain Aneurysm, I would include Mugabe and Gadaafi on my list of goodies. Mugabe was an anticolonial hero and instituted land reform, returning what was stolen by Euro colonists to indigenous Africans. Gadaafi, also an anticolonial hero, presided over the richest nation in all Africa and was a champion of African sovereignty and unity. The fact you consider both baddies shows what a lick spittle of Euro imperialism and opponent of anticolinial struggle you really are. Why am I not surprised? Socialist Posers Guardian Bros! Hurrah!
