Thomas_More

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,261 through 1,275 (of 1,685 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Lenin in his own words #234643
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    The quote by Stalin, above, shows too that he is not going for the later Bolshevik lie that socialism and communism are different things. He calls the future society socialism. Leninists of today will say no, he is describing communism, whilst what Stalin presides over is socialism, its precursor. Stalin himself here shows that that is NOT his real thinking at all!

    Also, as regards socialism springing independently from Russia’s peasant society, maybe it was the Makhnovists who temporarily made that work, very briefly, before the Reds exterminated them?!

    in reply to: Lenin in his own words #234599
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    And FLP Peking.

    in reply to: Russian Tensions #234514
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    I guess Kropotkin was a Nazi too, for opposing Lenin? Not to mention Rosa Luxemburg and Emma Goldmann?

    The Nazi Dalai Lama has written a superb book on science: The Universe in a Single Atom. I strongly recommend it. An excellent Nazi work!

    in reply to: Russian Tensions #234513
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    Don’t get me started on China, comrades! We’d soon go off thread.

    in reply to: Spiritual is material. #234473
    Thomas_More
    Participant
    in reply to: China is Capitalist #234471
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    And in China it was obligatory to read them, and anyone not showing the appropriate enthusiasm was punished.

    And this was a state that punished infants as young as six in the same way as adults, including breaking limbs etc.

    in reply to: China is Capitalist #234468
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    Right away, before even, at “liberation” the horrors and mass murders began. But tens of thousands of people resisted too, and cadres were also killed by angry villagers.

    All of this was over a decade before the “cultural revolution” of the sixties, which everyone mentions as though it was something different, so I hope that young resisters today aren’t believing that Maoism was somehow
    “better to begin with.”

    in reply to: China is Capitalist #234464
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    Mao handed down killing quotas for each province. Commissars vied to match or surpass these.

    One of the most prolific was Teng Hsiao-p’ing, who ruled the south-west.

    in reply to: Russian Tensions #234463
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    Will Putin really allow the annexed territories and Crimea to go to Ukraine?

    My guess is either:

    Next year will see a massive Russian blitzkrieg on Ukraine,

    Or: Putin has decided to hold the areas he has and will concentrate on defending them in a perpetual border war.

    in reply to: China is Capitalist #234454
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    First two years of “liberation” saw probably over two million executions (1950-52), mostly of poor villagers. Children as young as six were tortured, many committing suicide.

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 1 month ago by Thomas_More.
    in reply to: Russian Tensions #234437
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    And risking nuclear war is also irrational from every point of view, isn’t it? But they’re doing it.

    in reply to: Chinese Tensions #234429
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    It doesn’t seem real right now, that soon we will be dying horribly and everything about us destroyed. I still watch old movies on TV, I still read, I still function at home. It is the weather I like: sunny and crisp.

    I seem to have buried in the back of my mind my biggest fear. Yet it comes to the fore a few minutes after waking up in the morning, and every time the news sounds more menacing. Then I have to stop reading and go to bed.

    But still it doesn’t seem real.

    If it happens I want it instant and without warning. I don’t want a govt announcement or text. I don’t want to be regimented or made to take anti-radiation medicine, be forced to leave my home and my cats and be herded by police and soldiers.

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 1 month ago by Thomas_More.
    in reply to: Chinese Tensions #234428
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    You mean China.

    in reply to: Chinese Tensions #234426
    Thomas_More
    Participant

    So it looks like we are heading for WW3, and China won’t fail Russia over Ukraine, because it requires Russia as an ally in the coming conflagration.

    Thomas_More
    Participant

    But this was specifically England, and was prior to the Counter-Reformation – which transformed the Catholic Church into an apt vehicle for mercantile capitalism.

    I think your point would be better made in returning to an age when Catholicism did in fact represent feudalism, causing the rift between the Pope and the rest of the universal Church in 1054 (which held sway in non-feudal lands still under the old chattel slave system of Imperial Rome).

    The western Church changed with western European society from that time onward; the eastern Church stayed still, like Byzantium itself.

    The popes granted dispensations allowing the Lombards exemption from the usury laws and the Church was often in a position of championing – like in Liege – the rights of towns against nobles, as the towns increased in importance.

    Obviously, England has a unique history here, which cannot be transposed abroad.

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 1 month ago by Thomas_More.
Viewing 15 posts - 1,261 through 1,275 (of 1,685 total)