Xmas No. 1

November 2024 Forums Off topic Xmas No. 1

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 34 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #85098
    jondwhite
    Participant

    The "Friends of Jo Cox" have recorded a cover of The Rolling Stones' You Can't Always Get What You Want in tribute of the murdered MP. It features musicians such as Ricky Wilson from the Kaiser Chiefs, KT Tunstall and David Gray.

    https://www.theguardian.com/music/2016/dec/16/rolling-stones-royalties-jo-cox-tribute-single-christmas-no-1

    #124147
    rodmanlewis
    Participant

    Why do we need to be informed of this?

    #124148
    ALB
    Keymaster

    Yes, she was a careerist like the rest of them. One of those who wanted to dump Corbyn as he was harming her ascent of the greasy pole.

    #124149
    HollyHead
    Participant

    Let's not forget that in the sixties the Stones were thought to be heralding the collapse of society as we knew it…

    #124150
    jondwhite
    Participant

    Because more people listen to music than to us and if music can be political as in this explicit example why do some take a fundamentalist approach to it as unsocialist. The party even has its own song if I recall correctly. Also it's prominence in the news and the high profile of Xmas no 1 is an unconventional novel opportunity to challenge the notion we should pay tribute to those voting for war while they are also calling for gentler politics.

    #124151
    rodmanlewis
    Participant
    HollyHead wrote:
    Let's not forget that in the sixties the Stones were thought to be heralding the collapse of society as we knew it…

    Which goes to show that music, however "radical", changes nothing.

    #124152
    Bijou Drains
    Participant

    A suggestion for my Xmas no 1 would be "Winter's Song" by the Late Great Alan Hull. If Elvis Costello thinks it's the best song ever written then who am I to disagree. Also it's a song which expresses many of the feeling that Socialists have about the hypocrisy of this time of year.Hully was one of the unrecognised geniuses of working class music, in my humble opinion.As to the idea that music changes nothing, I disagree completely. Music and especially lyrics change the way people think. It may not, always be specifically Socialist, but songs such as "The Green Fields of France", "The Band Played Waltzing Matilda" or from my part of the world the songs of Tommy Armstrong, from the 1880-1920s  such as "The Oakey House Strike Evictions" and "The Durham Lockout" have influenced the way people think for generations. A well written song can get a message across in three minutes in ways that an academic discourse can never do. Anyway, it's late and I'm off to dream about a guy called Joe Hill

    #124153
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    The Cubans, Chilean, Argentinean, Portuguese, Brazilian, and Spaniard,  have  written, sang and distributed, ( Radio, Television, and Media )  around the world, and around Latin America,  thousands of the so called Protest Music, ( Trovas Cubanas,  Nueva Cancion )  with social lyrics, and with  the so called social content,  and they have not changed anything. Most of them are just blessing left wing governments, leftwing coups,  leaders, romantic social situations,  and worshipping  dictators. 

    #124154
    jondwhite
    Participant

    To clarify, Jo Cox didn't vote for war, but abstained. Angela Eagle is an example of an MP voting for war but calling for gentler politics.Jo Cox's partner Brendan Cox is delivering Channel 4's alternative Christmas message.

    #124155
    rodmanlewis
    Participant

    These people are railing against problems they in part are helping to maintain through their support of capitalism.I suppose anything is better than the Queen's Speech! I do remember some years ago certain politicians complained that her speech was too "internationalist" in tone.

    #124156
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    rodmanlewis wrote:
    HollyHead wrote:
    Let's not forget that in the sixties the Stones were thought to be heralding the collapse of society as we knew it…

    Which goes to show that music, however "radical", changes nothing.

    I wouldn't be that dismissive.  You may as well say that the 112 years existence of the SPGB has changed nothing either but you'd be wrong on both counts.  Whatever criticism one may have of John Lennon's Imagine, it remains the widest and best known lyrical encapsulation of the world we want to see, set to music.  And as far as the SPGB is concerned, it has, virtually single-handedly and for its entire existence, kept alive the case for real socialism and exposed the myth of socialism/communism having been tried and failed. 

    #124157
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    It will come as no surprise that I I would go with Imagine,  as I don't know of any other socialist song. Plenty of left wing, radical  and union songs but not socialist.I think music and comedy videos have  an important part to play in changing perceptions.Look at George Carlin for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJ4SSvVbhLw&list=RDkJ4SSvVbhLw#t=82and Monty Pythonhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rAaWvVFERVAThese are likely to impress workers more than an invitation to a lecture.

    #124158
    Wez
    Participant

    How about: 'Harvest for the World' by The Isley Brothers and 'Wake Up Everybody' by Harold Melvin and the Bluenotes? And I'm just gettin' warmed up.

    #124159
    rodmanlewis
    Participant
    Tim Kilgallon wrote:
    As to the idea that music changes nothing, I disagree completely. Music and especially lyrics change the way people think. It may not, always be specifically Socialist, but songs such as "The Green Fields of France", "The Band Played Waltzing Matilda" or from my part of the world the songs of Tommy Armstrong, from the 1880-1920s  such as "The Oakey House Strike Evictions" and "The Durham Lockout" have influenced the way people think for generations. A well written song can get a message across in three minutes in ways that an academic discourse can never do. Anyway, it's late and I'm off to dream about a guy called Joe Hill

    I suspect that they were mainly preaching to the converted. Perhaps we could ask how many members joined through hearing "socialist" songs or alternative comedians.Seems to me you only need to hear these songs once–there's no point in hearing them repeatedly. Rather like reciting the DoP regularly if you do.

    #124160
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    rodmanlewis wrote:
     Perhaps we could ask how many members joined through hearing "socialist" songs or alternative comedians.

    This is an interesting but  difficult question to address. We could ask that of any 'socialist activity'. I suspect socialist consciousness is more of a cummulative process. Very difficult to pin down the ONE thing that made you socialist.Anyway, I wish all comrades good will over Xmas and the rest of the year for that matter

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 34 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.