Socialist Party of Ireland pamphlets

November 2024 Forums World Socialist Movement Socialist Party of Ireland pamphlets

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #83784
    alanjjohnstone
    Keymaster
    #110743
    jondwhite
    Participant

    The Socialist Party of Ireland Manifesto (1949) is an official party pamphlet but The Irish Question: A Socialist Analysis (1976) is not. S.P.G.B. – Utopian or Scientific? The Fallacy of the Overwhelming Minority (1949) has the same party status as The Irish Question: A Socialist Analysis (1976). Neither were written or agreed by publications committee (or any other party committee). By contrast, Forum Journal (1952-1960) was written and agreed by a party committee, published regularly and has yet to be uploaded here despite being fully transcribed and requests to upload here.

    #110744
    alanjjohnstone
    Keymaster
    #110745
    jondwhite
    Participant
    alanjjohnstone wrote:

    It seems to be a party pamphlet.

    #110746
    ALB
    Keymaster
    jondwhite wrote:
    The Irish Question: A Socialist Analysis (1976) is not. S.P.G.B. – Utopian or Scientific? The Fallacy of the Overwhelming Minority (1949) has the same party status as The Irish Question: A Socialist Analysis (1976).

    This is pedantry and also insulting. True, both have the same "status" as non-party publications but "The Irish Question" was written by a socialist and puts the party case (in fact a large part of it had previously been published in the Socialist Standard). The other one is anti-socialist crap not worth the paper is was printed on and certainly not at all a priority for reproducing on the internet.

    #110747
    alanjjohnstone
    Keymaster

    My reasoning for drawing attention to those Irish pamphlets is that we do not possess a functioning World Socialist Party of Ireland, I think it is incumbent upon us to do our utmost to carry on the legacy of past Irish socialists until a revival of interest and new members are gained there.   

    #110748
    jondwhite
    Participant
    ALB wrote:
    jondwhite wrote:
    The Irish Question: A Socialist Analysis (1976) is not. S.P.G.B. – Utopian or Scientific? The Fallacy of the Overwhelming Minority (1949) has the same party status as The Irish Question: A Socialist Analysis (1976).

    This is pedantry and also insulting. True, both have the same "status" as non-party publications but "The Irish Question" was written by a socialist and puts the party case (in fact a large part of it had previously been published in the Socialist Standard). The other one is anti-socialist crap not worth the paper is was printed on and certainly not at all a priority for reproducing on the internet.

    I wasn't aware a large part of The Irish Question (1976) had been published in the Standard (and thus agreed by a party committee). I stand corrected. Apologies.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.