Orlando Figes on 1917

November 2024 › Forums › General discussion › Orlando Figes on 1917

  • This topic has 4 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 7 years ago by ALB.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • October 27, 2017 at 8:10 pm #85837
    jondwhite
    Participant

    Some tweets from Orlando Figes on 1917, any thoughts on the guy would be appreciated, I know a previous mention of him in the SS was critical

    Quote:
     

    Well I was in it but I wish I hadn't been – BBC2's – a crass, simplistic, cliché-ridden rendering of October 1917

    3 replies 7 retweets 22 likes
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     

    I've given 50+ media interviews on 1917 centenary in recent weeks around the world but none in the UK where media is pitifully at a loss

    13 replies 50 retweets 87 likes
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     

    1. original-tweet js-original-tweet

      ” data-conversation-id=”921755874389057536″ data-disclosure-type=”” data-follows-you=”false” data-item-id=”921755874389057536″ data-name=”Orlando Figes” data-permalink-path=”/orlandofiges/status/921755874389057536″ data-reply-to-users-json=”[{"id_str":"206040832","screen_name":"orlandofiges","name":"Orlando Figes","emojified_name":{"text":"Orlando Figes","emojified_text_as_html":"Orlando Figes"}}]” data-screen-name=”orlandofiges” data-tweet-id=”921755874389057536″ data-tweet-nonce=”921755874389057536-066412f8-1ab6-41c0-91bd-14186ade121d” data-tweet-stat-initialized=”true” data-user-id=”206040832″ data-you-block=”false” data-you-follow=”false”>

       

    2. original-tweet js-original-tweet

      ” data-conversation-id=”922172456365973505″ data-disclosure-type=”” data-follows-you=”false” data-item-id=”922172456365973505″ data-name=”Orlando Figes” data-permalink-path=”/orlandofiges/status/922172456365973505″ data-reply-to-users-json=”[{"id_str":"206040832","screen_name":"orlandofiges","name":"Orlando Figes","emojified_name":{"text":"Orlando Figes","emojified_text_as_html":"Orlando Figes"}}]” data-screen-name=”orlandofiges” data-tweet-id=”922172456365973505″ data-tweet-nonce=”922172456365973505-3b185615-72e0-43a6-9257-9a27fbee396e” data-tweet-stat-initialized=”true” data-user-id=”206040832″ data-you-block=”false” data-you-follow=”false”>

       

    3. original-tweet js-original-tweet

      ” data-conversation-id=”921801646845415424″ data-disclosure-type=”” data-follows-you=”false” data-item-id=”921801646845415424″ data-name=”Orlando Figes” data-permalink-path=”/orlandofiges/status/921801646845415424″ data-reply-to-users-json=”[{"id_str":"206040832","screen_name":"orlandofiges","name":"Orlando Figes","emojified_name":{"text":"Orlando Figes","emojified_text_as_html":"Orlando Figes"}}]” data-screen-name=”orlandofiges” data-tweet-id=”921801646845415424″ data-tweet-nonce=”921801646845415424-9ca5572a-fc7a-47a1-af73-967efd94bf3f” data-tweet-stat-initialized=”true” data-user-id=”206040832″ data-you-block=”false” data-you-follow=”false”>

       
      Oct 21

       

    4. original-tweet js-original-tweet

      ” data-conversation-id=”921801646845415424″ data-disclosure-type=”” data-follows-you=”false” data-item-id=”921801646845415424″ data-name=”Orlando Figes” data-permalink-path=”/orlandofiges/status/921801646845415424″ data-reply-to-users-json=”[{"id_str":"206040832","screen_name":"orlandofiges","name":"Orlando Figes","emojified_name":{"text":"Orlando Figes","emojified_text_as_html":"Orlando Figes"}}]” data-screen-name=”orlandofiges” data-tweet-id=”921801646845415424″ data-tweet-nonce=”921801646845415424-9ca5572a-fc7a-47a1-af73-967efd94bf3f” data-tweet-stat-initialized=”true” data-user-id=”206040832″ data-you-block=”false” data-you-follow=”false”>

       

    5. original-tweet js-original-tweet

      ” data-conversation-id=”921755874389057536″ data-disclosure-type=”” data-follows-you=”false” data-item-id=”921755874389057536″ data-name=”Orlando Figes” data-permalink-path=”/orlandofiges/status/921755874389057536″ data-reply-to-users-json=”[{"id_str":"206040832","screen_name":"orlandofiges","name":"Orlando Figes","emojified_name":{"text":"Orlando Figes","emojified_text_as_html":"Orlando Figes"}}]” data-screen-name=”orlandofiges” data-tweet-id=”921755874389057536″ data-tweet-nonce=”921755874389057536-066412f8-1ab6-41c0-91bd-14186ade121d” data-tweet-stat-initialized=”true” data-user-id=”206040832″ data-you-block=”false” data-you-follow=”false”>

       
      Oct 21

      Quote:
       

      I'm in Chile for a series of talks and events to mark the 1917 centenary. Here's one of a dozen – join me there: http://www.chile-canada-chamber.cl/041017/

      1. original-tweet js-original-tweet

        ” data-conversation-id=”912965979226955777″ data-disclosure-type=”” data-follows-you=”false” data-item-id=”912965979226955777″ data-name=”Orlando Figes” data-permalink-path=”/orlandofiges/status/912965979226955777″ data-reply-to-users-json=”[{"id_str":"206040832","screen_name":"orlandofiges","name":"Orlando Figes","emojified_name":{"text":"Orlando Figes","emojified_text_as_html":"Orlando Figes"}}]” data-screen-name=”orlandofiges” data-tweet-id=”912965979226955777″ data-tweet-nonce=”912965979226955777-0c2c06d5-1431-4724-8c1a-826322b73c06″ data-tweet-stat-initialized=”true” data-user-id=”206040832″ data-you-block=”false” data-you-follow=”false”>

         
         

        Russian TV series blaming Trotsky for October coup smells of anti-Semitism – https://www.timesofisrael.com/russian-tv-ser… via

         
        0 replies 1 retweet 14 likes
         
         
         
         
         
         
         
    6.  

  • original-tweet js-original-tweet

    ” data-conversation-id=”912965979226955777″ data-disclosure-type=”” data-follows-you=”false” data-item-id=”912965979226955777″ data-name=”Orlando Figes” data-permalink-path=”/orlandofiges/status/912965979226955777″ data-reply-to-users-json=”[{"id_str":"206040832","screen_name":"orlandofiges","name":"Orlando Figes","emojified_name":{"text":"Orlando Figes","emojified_text_as_html":"Orlando Figes"}}]” data-screen-name=”orlandofiges” data-tweet-id=”912965979226955777″ data-tweet-nonce=”912965979226955777-0c2c06d5-1431-4724-8c1a-826322b73c06″ data-tweet-stat-initialized=”true” data-user-id=”206040832″ data-you-block=”false” data-you-follow=”false”>

     
    Sep 27

October 27, 2017 at 8:12 pm #130262
jondwhite
Participant
Quote:
 I'm in Chile for a series of talks and events to mark the 1917 centenary. Here's one of a dozen – join me there: http://www.chile-canada-chamber.cl/041017/  Russian TV series blaming Trotsky for October coup smells of anti-Semitism – https://www.timesofisrael.com/russian-tv-series-claims-jewish-trotsky-masterminded-the-bloody-1917-revolution/ … via @timesofisrael 0 replies 1 retweet 14 likes           Orlando Figes‏ @orlandofiges Sep 27
October 27, 2017 at 8:14 pm #130263
jondwhite
Participant
Quote:
 17 July 1917: "spontaneous" demonstration or a failed Bolshevik coup? My latest blog on 1917 will soon be live: http://revolutionaryrussia.com Orlando Figes‏ @orlandofiges Jul 22   The Bolsheviks and Leather – thanks Susan Reed for putting the silly China Miéville right Russian Revolution 1 reply 5 retweets 32 likes           Orlando Figes‏ @orlandofiges Jul 17
October 28, 2017 at 11:17 am #130264
Sympo
Participant

There's a debate between him and (trotskyist) Alan Woods about the Russian Revolution. Both of them get pretty pissed off if I remember correctly. It's on YouTube (1 hour 14 minutes):Russian Revolution: Triumph or Tragedy – Alan Woods vs. Orlando Figes – YouTube

October 28, 2017 at 1:14 pm #130265
ALB
Keymaster

Earlier this month French television broadcast a documentary on Russia in 1917 . According to veteran Council Communist Henri Simon on a discussion forum, this showed well that "il ne s'agit pas d'une conquête des masses mais d'un coup d'état minutieusement préparé par une minorité politique très réduite" or, roughly translated:

Quote:
that it was not a question of a conquest by the masses but a carefully prepared coup d'état by a very small political minority.

Nice to find someone else from our milieu taking this view.

  • Author
    Posts
    • Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
    • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.