- Why are the answers in this FAQ so long?
Socialism is almost globally misunderstood and misrepresented.
Socialism will be a basic structural change to society, and many
of the things that most people take for granted, as "just the
way things have to be", can and must be changed to establish
socialism.
People tend to accept as true the things they hear over and
over again. But repetition doesn't make things true. Because
the truth and the facts often contradict "common knowledge",
socialists have to show that "common knowledge" is wrong. That
takes more words than just accepting the status quo.
- What is the World Socialist Movement (WSM)?
The World Socialist Movement is an organization which began with
the founding of the Socialist Party of Great Britain in 1904.
The Companion Parties of Socialism, which make up the World
Socialist Movement, are those parties sharing an understanding
of what socialism means, how to establish socialism, and a
scientific analysis of past and current society. For more
information about the WSM, see Introducing
the World Socialist Movement on the World Socialist
Movement web site.
- What makes the World Socialist Movement different?
Other parties sacrifice almost any "principle" to get elected or
stay in power. The sole object of the World Socialist Movement
is to establish socialism and the Companion Parties in the WSM
campaign only for socialism.
The World Socialist Movement couldn't run capitalism any
better than the other parties and so hasn't tried to get
elected to run capitalism (even with so-called "socialistic"
changes). Socialism will not come into existence by making
incremental changes to capitalism until it one day becomes
socialism, so the World Socialist Movement doesn't get side
tracked into attempts to improve capitalism.
The Companion Parties of Socialism base their arguments,
objects, and principles upon a scientific understanding of
society, not upon the latest trend or opinion poll or upon
some utopian dream.
Also, the World Socialist Movement is working for its own
demise. In socialism there will be no need for any political
parties.
For a fuller answer to this question, see Why the
World Socialist Movement is different from other groups
on the World Socialist Movement web site.
- Why doesn't the World Socialist Movement get involved in
social activism?
By "social activism" most people mean demonstrating, protesting,
or otherwise attempting to influence immediate events in
society, and still under capitalism. These attempts to reform
capitalism have a very long history: as long as capitalism
itself. We call these actions "reformism".
Organizations which claim to want socialism, and which also
promote reforms, ignore socialism and spend their time working
for reforms.
The Companion Parties of Socialism, in the World Socialist
Movement, are socialist parties. They promote socialism
because that is all a socialist party can promote.
If you find a "socialist" party promoting "social activism,"
you'll have found a non-socialist party.
- Who is your leader?
The World Socialist Movement doesn't have a leader, and nor do
any of the Companion Parties, because leadership is
undemocratic. If there are leaders, there must be followers:
people who just do what they are told.
In the World Socialist Movement, every individual member has
an equal say, and nobody tells the rest what to do. Decisions
are made democratically by the whole membership, and by
representatives or delegates. If the membership doesn't like
the decisions of those it elects, those administrators can be
removed from office and their decisions overridden.
Only when people have real, democratic control over their own
lives will they have the freedom that is socialism.
- Isn't socialism what they had in Russia, or in China or
Cuba, or in Sweden?
No. Socialism, as understood by the World Socialist Movement,
was never established in any country. A short definition of what
we understand to be socialism:
a system of society based upon the common ownership and
democratic control of the means and instruments for
producing and distributing wealth by and in the interest of
society as a whole.
- If there are wages and salaries, it is not socialism.
- State ownership is not socialism.
- Social programs are not socialism.
- Socialism means democracy at all levels of society,
including the workplace.
- Socialism means a wageless, moneyless society.
- Socialism means voluntary labour.
- Socialism means free access to the goods produced by
society.
With this understanding of socialism, the Socialist Party of
Great Britain noted in its journal, The Socialist Standard
(August 1918, page 87), that the supposedly "Marxist" Russian
Revolution of November 1917 was not socialist.
- Wouldn't everyone have to be altruistic for socialism to
work?
No. Socialism isn't based upon altruism. Socialism will work
even if everyone suddenly decides that they dislike everyone
else. Supporting socialism involves recognizing the fact that
the current system just doesn't work for most people. Socialism
will be a society in which satisfying an individual's self
interest is the result of satisfying everyone's needs. It is
enlightened self-interest that will work for the majority.
- How will socialism be established?
Socialism can only be established by a vast majority of people
deciding it wants to establish socialism. Therefore, the World
Socialist Movement puts forward the socialist case so that
people can decide for themselves.
Once the vast majority makes the decision in favour of
socialism, then it will elect socialist representatives or
delegates to prove its majority, and to serve as a temporary
focal point to administer the elimination of capitalism and
the creation of socialism. But it won't be, and could not be,
the elected representatives or delegates who create socialism,
it will be the people of the world as a whole.
The vast majority of the people of the world are working
class, so socialism will be established by the working class.
It also means that ordinary people will have to do all of the
work required. The capitalist class isn't going to do it, and
professional socialists (whatever they might be) aren't going
to do it. The only way to establish socialism is for people to
work for it.
- What if one country establishes socialism and others don't?
One country cannot establish socialism. No country is completely
self-sufficient in the resources people need to satisfy their
needs. No country can really isolate itself from the rest of the
world in a peaceful manner, so a peaceful "socialist nation"
would be easy prey for the outside capitalist world. Just as
capitalism is a world system, socialism will have to be a world
system.
Socialism will be a world without countries. Borders are just
artificial barriers that belong to a past and present that is
best left behind.
- What will socialism be like, how will it be administered?
The World Socialist Movement does not offer a blueprint for
administering a socialist society. For a small group of
socialists to do so would be undemocratic. It would also be
dumb. Socialists don't have crystal balls to determine what the
conditions will be when socialism is established. As the
socialist majority grows, when socialism is within the grasp of
the working class, then will be the proper time for making such
important decisions.
The only thing socialists can say now, about administration,
is that socialism is only socialism if it is democratic.
- The World Socialist Movement talks of a moneyless society,
does that mean we'll use the barter system?
In a socialist society, there will be no money and no barter.
Goods will be voluntarily produced, and services voluntarily
supplied to meet people's needs. People will freely take the
things they need.
- What about human nature?
Humans behave differently depending upon the conditions that
they live in. Even very short term changes in those conditions
can change the way people behave. Most of what people refer to
as "human nature" is actually human behaviour: reactions to the
world around them.
Human behaviour reflects society. In a society such as
capitalism, people's needs are not met and reasonable people
feel insecure. People tend to acquire and hoard goods because
possession provides some security. People have a tendency to
distrust others because the world is organized in such a
dog-eat-dog manner.
Under capitalism, and the previous systems, people have good
reason to worry about tomorrow - they can lose their jobs, or
be injured, or grow old, and need a cushion of wealth to fall
back on. In a socialist society, everyone is entitled to have
their needs met. They won't be kicked out onto the street, or
forced to give up the pleasures of life. There will be no
poverty. The "cushion" will be cooperatively provided by all.
- But why will people work if they don't have to?
People will have to work, but it will be voluntary. If people
didn't work society would obviously fall apart. To establish
socialism the vast majority must consciously decide that they
want socialism and that they are prepared to work in socialist
society.
- Work is part of human life. Today rich people work when
they don't have to, because they, like many of the rest of
us, enjoy working. Many people work harder at their hobbies
than they do at work. It is the nature of employment that
makes it "work" instead of pleasure. Work needn't be a part
of the day that we wish would end.
- People enjoy creating useful things. Instead of producing
junk that people only buy because they can't afford quality,
every worker will be able to produce quality products for
themselves and others, and know that other workers will be
doing the same.
- The workday will be shortened. Many jobs (such as those
dealing with money, or war, or poverty) will not be required
at all. The people doing those jobs now, will perform work
that actually produces goods and services that people want.
- People will gain respect for doing jobs that others might
find unpleasant, or the unpleasant jobs might be shared
around. Many of the unpleasant jobs could be made more
pleasant and some could be done away with.
- Does socialism mean equal shares for everyone?
No. People are different and have different needs. Some needs
will be more expensive (in terms of resources and labour needed
to satisfy them) than others.
- What if people want too much?
In a socialist society "too much" can only mean "more than is
sustainably produced." If people decide that they (individually
and as a society) need to over-consume then socialism cannot
possibly work.
Under capitalism, there is a very large industry devoted to
creating needs. It tells us we need toilet seat warmers, nifty
gadgets (that don't work), new this and that, and attempts to
convince us that our human worth is dependent upon our
material wealth. Capitalism requires consumption, whether it
improves our lives or not, and drives us to
consume up to, and past, our ability to pay for that
consumption. On top of that, goods are not built to last
because that would interfere with profit making.
Socialism will be a very different society. Goods will be
built to last. The buy-buy-buy advertising industry will no
longer exist. People may decide that they have better things
to do rather than produce goods that are widely seen to be
extravagances. And people may discover that more material
goods don't make them happier.
Society already has the knowledge and technology to satisfy
all of our basic needs sustainably. There is every reason to
believe that socialist society will supply every human being
with all the material goods that they need for a comfortable,
pleasant, enjoyable life.
- What about the environment?
The environment that is pleasant for human beings is being
destroyed because of economic factors inherent in capitalism. At
best, with the best intentions of everybody, capitalism can only
do too little, too late. Government cannot stop the destruction,
it can only slow down the worst of it for a while. If
environmental protection rules make production less profitable,
then production may move out, the economy will take a nosedive
and the environmental rules will be relaxed.
The solution is to change the economic system. In a socialist
world, there will be no profit. Production will be
democratically decided. The human need for a livable
eco-system will be considered as a normal part of all decision
making.
- How will people who disagree be treated in socialism?
Those who disagree will be treated like anyone else. If a person
or group decided to start promoting a return to capitalism, or
some other class-divided social form, they would be free to do
so. If however, a person or group, was damaging society (beating
people up, or blowing up buildings, etc.) then society will take
appropriate action against them.
Freedom must include allowing disagreement with the status quo
and spreading unpopular ideas, but freedom does not include
hurting people or destroying the common wealth of humanity.
Exactly what methods a future socialist society will
democratically choose to use, if people need to protect
themselves, are beyond the ability of the World Socialist
Movement to predict, but one can expect that those methods
will be more humane and less dictated by blanket policies than
the methods used today.
- How will problems be handled in socialism?
Many of today's problems, such as poverty, will not even exist
in a socialist society. Of course, no human society will ever be
without problems. A socialist society will have to deal, democratically
and cooperatively, with the problems as they arise.
An example of a major problem: even under capitalism, natural
disasters generate tremendous volunteer effort and people
donate huge amounts of goods, services, and money to help
those who are suffering. It is not conceivable that this human
response will decrease in socialism. Without the profit
constraints of capitalism, such major problems can be dealt
with quickly and satisfactorily.